ActiveRecord: count vs size vs length on associations

Posted About 11 years ago. Visible to the public. Repeats. Linked content.

TL;DR: You should generally use #size to count associated records.

size

  • Counts already loaded elements
  • If the association is not loaded, falls back to a COUNT query

count

  • If a counter cache is set up, returns the cached value
  • Issues a COUNT query else

Caveats

  • If you trigger a COUNT query for an association of an an unsaved record, Rails will try to load all children where the foreign key IS NULL. This is not what you want. To prevent this behavior, you can use unsaved_record.association.to_a.size.
  • count looks directly into the database, neglecting already loaded elements. This becomes a problem when you use that "db count" and process the loaded elements.
    A common example is tests: Imagine a test that sets up a few records and finishes the test setup by asserting a number of associated records. If you use .count for that job, the assertion cannot see that the setup records have loaded (i.e. cached) their associations too early and now are missing elements. Tests relying on the setup will fail, because they will operate on the loaded records. You will hardly notice, because you rely on the assertion. Using .size avoids this problem.

length

  • Loads all records from the database, then returns the number of elements
web.archive.org
Dominik Schöler
makandra.de
Say thanks4
Last edit
4 days ago
Dominik Schöler
Keywords
has_many, scope, relation
License
Source code in this card is licensed under the MIT License.

Related cards:

Updated: ActiveRecord: count vs size vs length on associations

  • Added another caveat of #count

    count looks directly into the database, neglecting already loaded elements. This becomes a problem when you use that "db count" when processing the loaded elements.
    A common example is tests: Imagine a test...

Security issues with hash conditions in Rails 2 and Rails 3

Find conditions for scopes can be given either as an array (:conditions => ['state = ?', 'draft']) or a hash (:conditions => { 'state' => 'draft' }). The later is nicer to read, but has horrible security implications in some versions of Ru...

Capybara - The missing API

The Capybara API is somewhat hard for parse for a list of methods you can call on a Capybara node. Below you can find such a list. It's all copied from the Capybara docs, so all credit goes to the Ca...

Merging two arbitrary ActiveRecord scopes

(Rails has a method ActiveRecord::Relation#merge that can merge ActiveRecord scopes. However, its behavior has never been clear, and in Rails 7 it still discards conditions on the same column by the last condition. **We disco...

ActiveRecord::Relation#merge overwrites existing conditions on the same column

In Ruby on Rails ActiveRecord::Relation#merge overwrites existing conditions on the same column. This may cause the relation to select more records than expected:

authorized_users = User.where(id: [1, 2])
filtered_users   = User.where(i...

Rails: When defining scopes with class methods, don't use `self`

Sometimes it is useful to define a named scope by implementing a static method with the scope's name on the scoped class. For instance, when a method should decide which existing scope should be the next link in the scope chain. Take this class fo...

ActiveRecord: scoped `validates_uniqueness_of` allows one null value per scope

As you most likely know validates_uniqness_of :foreign_id does not allow nil values by default.

To allow nil one has to set the :allow_nil => true option.

Very unexpected scoping this validation will **not raise an error if foreign_id ...

Rails: When to use :inverse_of in has_many, has_one or belongs_to associations

When you have two models in a has_many, has_one or belongs_to association, the :inverse_of option in Rails tells ActiveRecord that they're two sides of the same association.

Example with a has_many / belongs_to association:

c...

Preloaded associations are filtered by conditions on the same table

When you eagerly load an association list using the .include option, and at the same time have a .where on an included table, two things happen:

  1. Rails tries to load all involved records in a huge single query spanning multiple database tab...

Traverse an ActiveRecord relation along an association

The Edge Rider gem gives your relations a method #traverse_association which
returns a new relation by "pivoting" around a named association.

Say we have a Post model and each Post belongs to an aut...

Posted by Dominik Schöler to makandra dev (2013-03-13 09:38)
This website uses short-lived cookies to improve usability.
or learn more